Yuku free message boards

I don't disagree with the concept of a living language. However, without a commonality in the language upon which educated speakers can agree, you soon lose any sense of a common language across the United States, as regionalisms would become the order of the day. Worst case, you end up with: "Any way they is spoke it will been all good."

In other words, while recognizing that the language will change, there still needs to be a basic set of rules to be taught; a framework - skeleton, if you will - upon which the language may be fleshed out. In the same way that my face and body will differ from yours, but it still performs in recognizable ways, and when I smile you still understand the expression, thus language needs those recognizable functions that let even regional differences most often be intelligible to the listener.

I think a mixture of "prescriptive" and "descriptive" grammarian is best, for that reason.

Writing is where I lean toward prescription. In writing, except for personal messages, you have to keep in mind that you are writing for a broader audience who might not share your frame of reference. This is where rules and a common parlance are most useful